American data centre politics have arrived in Britain. Zack Polanski, the Green party leader, spent Friday at the site of a proposed facility in East London telling the BBC it was time to slam the brakes on these energy-guzzling, water-guzzling datacentres. His party wants a pause on approvals for anything other than local-scale centres, and the response from Labour was immediate and unsentimental: a moratorium would be a disaster for jobs and national security.
The timing is what gives the intervention weight, as the Guardian reported. The country is partway through one of its worst droughts in years, July came in as the driest on record in England and Wales, and the sector’s electricity appetite, running at roughly two and a half per cent of UK supply today, is forecast by government-adjacent projections to quadruple by 2030. A large facility can draw as much power as a medium-sized town. On water, the Water Research Centre estimates data centres in England use around 1.9 billion litres a year, about 0.2 per cent of the non-household market, with a clear upward trend. Industry points out golf courses use more. Both halves of that sentence are true at once, which is why the argument is not going away.
Polanski’s sharper target was not the numbers but a 2024 decision to designate data centres as critical infrastructure, putting them on the legal footing of hospitals and transport networks. Critical infrastructure is water, electricity, hospitals, he said, it isn’t AI for tech billionaires, and he wants developers to prove their water use is sustainable before drawing on public reserves. Friends of the Earth is asking for a moratorium until proper assessments exist. The government’s line, reported by POLITICO, is that it is not writing blank cheques for big tech either, while insisting that pausing construction cedes the AI race to America and the Gulf.
Strip the rhetoric and both sides are arguing about the same unsettled question: who verifies the local costs. Planning decisions on these facilities are made against project-specific assessments commissioned by the developer, water companies have said government growth forecasts failed to account for their consumption, and communities discover the grid connection queue position after the objections window. The Centre for Net Zero’s Rosa Curling welcomed the government’s blank-cheque language and then noted that without urgent action on transparency, that is exactly what happens anyway.
Britain wants the investment, the jobs and the compute sovereignty, and the constituencies hosting the facilities want metered water, grid impact studies and a business rates story that adds up locally. Those wants are reconcilable, but only by a government willing to regulate the sector in public rather than champion it in private. The pause debate opened Friday will not close before the next planning committee does.