Would it be possible to permanently eliminate the “forever” chemicals that contaminate our water and are toxic? Enspired Solutions was founded in Michigan by chemical engineer Meng Wan and environmental toxicologist Denise Kay. They left behind corporate consulting to tackle one of the biggest environmental problems: PFAS.
Kay says that PFAS has been referred to by some as an everlasting chemical due to its resistance to breakdown. It does not naturally break down in the environment so it keeps going around. The chemistry that would interrupt the cycle, and separate the molecules, could be a great way to improve the health of everyone.
The decision to base the business in Michigan was a pragmatic and strategic one. The state has been a leader in PFAS regulation with a startup infrastructure–buoyed by the Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC)–that helped turn an ambitious vision into a viable business.
The MEDC programs provided Kay and Wang with the tools they needed to build their PFASigator, a device the size of two refrigerators which uses ultraviolet light to breakdown PFAS. It essentially “eats” PFAS.
The journey was far from easy, despite the MEDC’s support. “As people say, being an entrepreneur and running a startup is like a rollercoaster,” Kay says. “You have high moments, and you have very low moments when you think nothing’s ever going to move forward.”
In the beginning, without revenue or salary in order to sustain the co-founders’ motivation, they had no other option than to rely on something more.
“If problem solving and learning new talents do not provide sufficient intrinsic reward for a founder to be satisfied throughout what I guarantee will be a long duration effort, then that founder may need to reset their expectations. Because the financial rewards of entrepreneurship are small throughout the process.”
Kay is still optimistic for the future of Enspired Solutions and clean water innovations, as well as for founders who are on a similar road. “Often, founders are coached about formulas for fundraising, formulas for startup success. Learning those formulas and expectations is important, but it’s also important to not forget that it’s your creativity and innovation and foresight that got you to the place you’re in and drove you to start a company. Ultimately, people still want to see that shine through.”
The Michigan Economic Development Corporation is a partner in the production of this episode.
The Full Transcript
Megan Tatum: Megan Tatum is MIT Technology Review’s Megan Tatum. Business Lab is the program that helps leaders in business make sense of emerging technologies.
This episode was produced in collaboration with Michigan Economic Development Corporation.
Today’s topic is the launch of a tech startup in Michigan, a state located in the United States. To turn an innovative product or company into reality, you need knowledge and resources which may not be available to individuals. The Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC) has created an innovative campaign in order to help technology entrepreneurs.
Startup ecosystem is a two-word phrase that you should know.
Denise Kay is my guest. She’s the CEO and co-founder of Enspired Solutions in Michigan, a startup that focuses on removing PFAS, or synthetic chemicals, from water.
Welcome, Denise.
Dr. Denise Kay: Hi, Megan.
Megan: Hi. We are so glad you could join us. Denise: I was wondering if you could tell us a little bit about Enspired Solutions to get things started. What is your business and how did you come up with the idea?
Denise: My co-founder Meng and I both had consulting careers, where we advised clients about the fate and toxic effects of chemicals on the environment. We evaluated how chemicals move through the soil, air and water and their toxic effects on people and wildlife. This put us in a unique position of being able to assess the health and environmental impacts early in the life cycle of man-made chemicals.
We could see the importance of making this chemistry commercially available and its potential to have a positive impact in maintaining healthy water for us all.
As you have mentioned, the PFAS chemical is often referred to as an everlasting chemical due to its resistance to breakdown. The molecule does not naturally break down in the environment. It just keeps going around. The chemistry that would interrupt the cycle, and separate the molecules, could be a great way to improve the health of everyone.
Enspired Solutions was founded by Meng, who quit her job and me. We wanted to create, manufacture and sell equipment for commercial use that would destroy PFAS from water using the chemistry discovered in laboratory benches. Our goal was to ensure that this toxic substance did not circulate within our natural resources.
We have already won awards from both the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) and Department of Defense and tested our technology on over 200 water samples, including groundwater, surface waters, landfill leachate and industrial wastewater. [and] Municipal wastewater You can find it everywhere. We’re currently seeing customers use our applications to manage semiconductor waste. The groundwater and surface waters around airports are often high in PFAS. PFAS contaminated liquids can be collected and managed in central waste disposal sites. Even the transition of firetrucks from PFAS foams to PFAS free firefighting fluids is possible.
Megan: Fantastic. This is a wide range of possibilities, amazing stuff.
Denise: Yeah.
Megan: Your company was launched four years ago. What factors led you to choose Michigan as the best place for your company’s growth?
Denise: We thought about it a great deal because Meng and I both live in Illinois. “Okay, what is going to be our headquarters?” A number of factors were considered.
We looked at a few things that could be used as incubators. Startup incubators and innovation centers are what I meant by incubator. Startup support networks, a future employee pool, and the position of state agencies on PFAS are all important.
In Michigan, while thinking of all these things and researching our local communities, we rented a place where we could conduct chemistry experiments within an incubator. We knew we needed to be surrounded by entrepreneurs. Although we were excellent chemists and knew how to work with other people, it was important that we surround ourselves with others who had the skills needed.
We also know that Michigan is much more aggressive than any other state in identifying PFAS in the environment, and regulating their presence. We knew that this combination would allow us to start our business successfully.
Megan: This was the perfect place for these two reasons. How did you begin your relationship with Michigan Economic Development Corporation (MEDC)?
Denise: Both my cofounder Meng and myself are new entrepreneurs. MEDC was the first resource I contacted after a Google Search. We used them as a resource for information at first, but also to learn some basic skills. We also received expert mentoring for business contracts, intellectual property, forecasting and tracking our finances and how to raise money.
Megan: Wow. They must have been a valuable resource back then. What was the progress of early-stage R&D from this point on? How did you get your business started using MEDC programs and services?
Denise: Our business relies on truly cutting edge science. It was important to understand the intellectual landscape. This is the term that describes intellectual property such as patents, trademarks and trade secrets. These are all related to the science on which we founded our company. We wanted to make sure we started on the right path and wouldn’t run into a brick wall in three years.
MEDC conducted an IP Landscape Survey for us. The MEDC searched for patents and applications and trademarks and gave us that information to consider before investing a great deal of time and energy into the business.
MEDC helped us create an Excel model for business finance and forecasting early on, so we were proactive rather than reactive when it came to our financial constraints. It was obvious that it would be expensive to build and design a piece that is the same size as two refrigerators. This type of forward-looking financial modeling allowed us to determine when we needed to begin fundraising and securing investments. The MEDC provided us with an attorney to review contract language and ensure that we understood the agreements we signed.
Megan: Right. As you said, you and your partner were both first-time business owners. Business acumen is very different from tech acumen. What was it like to develop this new technology and also build a business plan?
Denise: Meng, on the other hand, is an incredibly intelligent person. She has a MBA and is also a chemical engineering. Meng was able to understand how business functions, as well as the engineering and chemistry involved in what we wanted to achieve.
By training, I’m an environmental toxicologist. In that area, I have a more extensive career than Meng. In the past, I established and grew new offices at different consulting firms that I worked for. From that perspective, I was familiar with the people, spaces, cultures, and business management. Meng is a financial MBA with the knowledge base to run a successful business. Both of us are excellent engineers and chemists.
At least, we had the knowledge to make the first step. It was a challenge to work 24 hours a day with no income. The MEDC and other startup support networks became indispensable.
We simply couldn’t do all that we needed, particularly while learning. MEDC, and other programs, provided us with support, which helped to relieve some of the burden, while also helping us learn how to use our new skills efficiently, resulting in less stumbles.
Megan: There are so many aspects to consider when starting your own business. In that vein, I was wondering if you could share with us some of your successes and highlights so far. Could you share any exciting partnerships or projects with us that excite you?
Denise: People say that being an entrepreneur or running a start-up is similar to riding a rollercoaster. There are highs and lows. You may think that nothing will ever move forward. Let’s talk about a few highlights. We call it the PFASigator.
The story of how this name was chosen is a funny one. Like I said, the machine is about as big as two refrigerators. The machine is very big and breaks down PFASs in water. It takes water with PFAS, adds liquid chemicals and then shines an intense UV light on it. This catalyzes the chemical reaction known as reductive fluorination. To an outsider it still looks like water when all this happens and the PFAS molecule is being broken down into nontoxic compounds. The machine, however, is large and eats the PFAS.
Meng was bantering with me, while her son, who is only six years old, was standing in the back. We called each other names. Thomas shouted out. “The PFASigator!” It was like this: “Ooh, there’s something there.”
Megan: This is a fantastic name.
Denise: The name is memorable and fits our work. This has been a lot of fun. This was a highlight from the beginning, so we stuck with it.
Standing next to the first PFASigator that was fully functional, I would say this is the next best thing. The PFASigator was huge. All stainless steel. Meng and I hadn’t been involved in building such a large, physical object. It was thrilling to stand there and see the image of ourselves. It was an amazing feeling.
We received champagne for everyone who sold our first machine. I believe we were eight people at the time.
Megan: Fantastic.
Denise: They call the transition from a startup selling nothing to having sold something, “you’ve gone from zero to one”. This was an important milestone for us.
Enspired was awarded an exciting project recently in Michigan. As it is still in contracting, I cannot reveal any details. It is with a progressive municipal that our PFASigator will be permanently installed to destroy PFAS. This kind of progress from zero to 1, and then an important contract which will increase the visibility and effectiveness of our machine and approach, have really boosted our energy. We are having a positive impact on water sustainability. We started our company to do just that.
Megan: Awesome. There are some amazing milestones. As you said, it is a difficult journey to be an entrepreneur. What advice, based on your experience, would you give to budding entrepreneurs?
Denise: If solving problems and learning new skills do not satisfy a founder, I advise them to adjust their expectations. The financial benefits of being an entrepreneur are minimal throughout the entire process.
Meng put and I [in] We used some personal money and did not take any salary. For at least an year and half, we worked harder than ever before. During the startup process, financial rewards will be small. In many cases the rewards come later, or never at all.
You’ll either be an unhappy founder if you don’t enjoy the tough road ahead and are intrinsically motivated to do so.
Megan: You need to have a passion for the job you do at Enspired Solutions.
Denise: You’re right, but I would like to add one more thing.
Megan: Yes, of course.
Denise: Many founders receive coaching on formulas to raise money and formulas that will help them succeed as a startup. It’s important to learn these formulas and to understand what’s expected of you, but don’t forget your own creativity, innovation and vision that brought you here and pushed you to launch a business. People still want that to shine through.”
Megan: This is a great piece of advice. Thank you so much, Denise.
It was Dr. Denise Kay who I spoke to from Brighton in England, which had an unseasonably sunny day.
This is the end of this Business Lab episode. I’m your host, Megan Tatum. I am a contributor editor and host at Insights. This is the division for custom publishing of MIT Technology Review. The Massachusetts Institute of Technology founded us in 1899. We are in the print media, online, and on events around the globe every year. For more information about us and the show, please check out our website at technologyreview.com.
You can listen to this show wherever you download podcasts. We hope that you will take the time to review and rate this episode. Business Lab, a production by MIT Technology Review and this particular episode were produced by Giro Studios. Thank you for listening.
The content of this article was created by Insights – the custom content division of MIT Technology Review. This content was not created by MIT Technology Review.
The content of this website was designed and created by humans, including writers, editors and analysts. The writing and collecting of survey data is included. AI tools were only used in secondary production that was human reviewed.