Even though the asteroid could have killed thousands of people, it could still crash into the moon. The models for Asteroid 2024YR4 predict that it will impact Earth around December 2032. The asteroid has a lower chance of impacting the Earth since those previous predictions. However, its chances to hit the Moon have increased. The likelihood of an impact on the moon is currently around 4 percent.
In spite of this small probability, scientists have already begun to consider possible prevention strategies aimed at deflecting the asteroid or destroying it before its impact. A team of NASA scientists, as well as other scientists, published on arXiv in September 2025 a paper weighing the pros and cons of possible interventions. One option was to use nuclear devices to blast an asteroid. What will actually happen, if scientists decide to set off nuclear devices on the surface or close by of 2024-YR4?
Click here to read more: Asteroid has a 1% chance of impacting Earth in 2032 – Should we be worried? Nuking Asteroids 2024-YR4 and 19659005 Although the tests are limited, scientists believe that the nuclear device could destroy or deflect 2024-YR4.
In order to deflect an asteroid scientists will detonate nuclear devices around selected surfaces, which would obliterate one face and change its trajectory by creating thrust. To destroy the asteroid scientists will fire a nuclear weapon straight at its core and smash it to smithereens. The authors of the study claim that nuclear deflection will not be possible for 2024, regardless of whether researchers reuse existing spacecraft or build new ones. The team’s paper stated that “deflection missions have been assessed and seem impractical” due to the limited information available about the structure of the asteroid. While scientists know the diameter of the asteroid — 220 feet, as per NASA — they don’t have much information about its composition or mass, both factors that would affect a nuclear deflection strategy. While a reconnaissance flight could provide more information about the asteroid and the necessary details for a nuclear-deflection plan, it is unlikely to happen before the 2024 YR4 deadline. Nuclear Destruction or Robust Disruption?
According to the researchers, the best option is nuclear “robust destruction” or destruction, which would involve blasting the asteroid into pieces before approaching it with two nuclear weapons. In their study, authors suggest that only one device would be needed to destroy an asteroid. The second device could then serve as backup, in case the first is not enough. The team said in their paper that “nuclear robust destruction missions” are available, with launches scheduled between 2029-2031.
There are other, non-nuclear, options, such as smashing the asteroid into pieces using a spacecraft, to deflect or destroy it. The paper states that “robust disrupt” missions are available between April 2020 and April 2032. Deflection will be less effective than destruction with these “kinetic” methods. The paper says that A City-Killer Asteroid Will Not Harm the Earth but It Could Hit the Moon
A Nuke-Free Approach. A no-nuke approach? The impact of 2024 YR4 on the Moon’s surface would cause a massive crater, which would send significant debris to Earth. Some of the debris will burn in Earth’s atmospheric, but some may remain, which could increase micrometeoroid impact and threaten satellites including the ISS. The authors of the study say that asteroid-prevention strategies need to be developed, regardless of whether the 2024 YR4 models continue to predict collisions. The team’s paper states that “the lunar impact will most likely be either ruled in or out” by 2028 when the asteroid is closest to the moon. This would occur before 2032. Even if the lunar impact was ruled out there would still be significant utility to deploying a mission to characterize and study the asteroid.
Continue reading: Increased Chances for City-Killer Asteroids Impacting the Moon from 3.8 Percent to 4.3 per cent
The Article the Sources
Discovermagazine.com writers use high-quality peer-reviewed sources and studies The sources for this article are listed below:
- NASA. NASA Facts about 2024 YR4
- NASA. Dark Skies Provide New Observations on Asteroid 2024 YR4, Lowering Impact Probability.
- NASA. NASA’s Webb observations update Asteroid 2024-YR4 impact odds on the Moon
- arXiv. NASA Space Mission Options for Reconnaissance and Mitigation of Asteroid YR4 (19659028). NASA’s Update on Asteroid Size Estimates and Lunar Impact Probabilities